How Shoes Can Cause Joint Pain
Can you guess what the largest joint in your body is? If you guessed the knee, youd be right! As the largest joint in your body, your knee is powerful, and its also the most susceptible to injury. The best way to protect your knee, which also protects your hips and spine, is to make sure youre wearing the right shoes. Heres a breakdown of the kind of shoes you need to avoid, so you can avoid breakdown to your important joints!
Shoes You Should Avoid
The two main types of shoes to avoid are high heels and flip-flops. The reason high heels are so bad for you is because they shift forward your center of gravity. This means your body has to use different muscles in order to try to keep you upright in a way that it wasnt made to. This can cause muscle imbalances that lead to misalignments in your spine and unnecessary stress and strain on other joints joints like your knees.
A recent study published in the Journal of Orthopedic Research found that wearing high heels over three inches can prematurely age your knee joints and cause arthritis. No fashion statement is worth irreversible joint damage that can lead to lifelong pain.
What is the Right Shoe?
Reviews For The Best And Worst Shoes For Arthritis
Experts are united in their low opinion of high heels, defined as heels higher than 2 inches. High heels are bad for everyones feet, and for people with any kind of arthritis, theyre even worse. Theyre hard on the arch and ball of the foot and can wear down joints, says Bryan West, a podiatric surgeon who practices in Livonia, Mich.
Studies show wearing stilettos and other heels contributes to both foot pain and arthritis. Researchers at Iowa State University in Ames measured forces on the knee in women wearing flats and wearing 2-inch and 3.5-inch heels. Women who made a habit of wearing high heels had an increased risk of knee joint degeneration and knee osteoarthritis, or OA. Risk as well as the frequency of low back pain rose with the height of the heel, according to their study, presented at the 2010 annual meeting of the American Society of Biomechanics.
In a study, published in Arthritis & Rheumatism, Hannan found that women with a history of wearing high heels also experienced more foot pain later in life than those who opted for healthier shoes.
Kirstens Pick: Earthies, a new line of high heels by earth footwear that features a cupped heel, anatomical arch and cradle toe area to distribute weight evenly.
These can produce the same problems as higher heels, just to a lesser degree. Add a pointy toe and you can have even more discomfort.
Tips For Buying New Running Shoes
The Twist Test
When running, the foot flexes, so to ensure a natural stride the shoe needs to crease at the same flex point as your foot. This flex point in the shoe should occur at the same position as the balls of your feet. A shoe that is too flexible fails the Twist Test. If you hold the shoe at both ends and twist the shoe it should feel firm in order to provide adequate support. However, a shoe without proper support tends to twist easily and isnt suitable for running.
Sometimes its difficult to know when its time for new running shoes since we tend to adapt to the discomfort they cause over time. To avoid doing more harm than good, it is recommended that runners buy a new pair of running shoes halfway through the life expectancy of your current shoes and rotate between the two. Should the difference in comfort be significant between the two pairs, its time for the older pair to retire.
Hopefully, with these 5 five signs its time to replace your running shoes, you can take your best foot forward in a pain-free run. Still feeling pain after having replaced your running shoes? Perhaps there is a bigger issue.
At The Foot Hub, our Sydney podiatrists specialise in biomechanical foot assessments to help pinpoint key problem areas in your gait that may not be easily corrected by a simple change of running shoes. Why be walking on sunshine, when you could be running on sunshine? Book an appointment online or call us on 02 8096 4763.
Also Check: Dcf Compression Knee Sleeve
Pain Behind Or Around Your Kneecap
The most common cause of knee pain is your kneecap rubbing against the lower end of your thighbone instead of gliding smoothly over it. That friction damages the cartilage beneath your kneecap, in some cases wearing it all the way down to the bone.
- Overuse, the most common factor among active people.
- Muscle weakness in your thighs and hips, which prevents them from properly stabilizing your knee.
- Your gait. Too much inward collapse of your knee as you run or walka common problemresults in extra stress to your knee joint and kneecap.
- Overpronation, which also stresses your knee as your lower leg turns inward while your thigh rotates your knee outward.
- Aging and/or osteoarthritis, which contributes to the softening or breaking down of cartilage.
- Trauma, such as a blow to your knee that damages or breaks off part of the cartilage or bone.
The Link Between The Foot And Knee
Your feet and knees are linked literallyit should come as no surprise that one affects the other when it comes to pain! The amount of impact generated when you walk, the way your feet are aligned, and the way that force is distributed as you take each step has a significant impact not only on your feet and heels themselves, but on your knees!
Orthotics are a tried and true way to drastically improve foot painheres what you need to know about the connection between orthotics and knee pain!
Don’t Miss: Ginger Poultice For Arthritis
Wear The Right Footwear
Many people do not realise that their foot pain comes from wearing the wrong type of shoes. Your shoes will not just affect your ankle and foot but also your knees.
Shoes are not just there for fashion, but they act as a support for your ankle, foot and knee. People who are already suffering from knee pain might want to consult specialty shops in order to get something tailored just for them.
This can depend on a lot of things including how you walk and how your foot looks, i.e. if you have high arches or flat feet.
Even if you dont have pain in your foot or ankle, make sure to still wear the right footwear depending on what activity you are doing. For example, hiking and playing basketball are two different activities that would require different footwear. Wearing the right type will prevent foot pain or any other injuries.
Types Of Shoes That Can Cause Knee Pain
You may have a favorite style of shoes, but they might not be the best shoes for your feet. Flip- flops are one shoe style thats particularly bad for your feet. They may be comfortable and easy to wear, but they usually lack support. Shoes that are unsupportive tend to misalign your hips, putting more pressure on your knees.
High heels are attractive and many women love to wear them. But a study by the Orthopaedic Research Society found that wearing high heels increased the risk for knee osteoarthritis.
Wearing the wrong shoes changes the way you walk, also known as your gait. And that can also put pressure on your knees, contributing to knee pain.
Don’t Miss: What Rebuilds Cartilage
What Kinds Of Shoes Should You Be Wearing
Women, particularly professionals, often feel required to wear heels in order to be perceived as well-dressed. However, high heels cause you to walk in an unnatural way, with your weight pushed forward onto your toe bones. Stilettos take that to a more extreme level, shifting even more of your weight forward and providing little stability in the back, making it very easy to sprain your ankle. In extreme cases, too much pressure on the front of the foot can even cause hairline fractures in your bones.
If you need to wear high heels above two inches, look for a cupped heel, a cradle toe area, and an anatomical arch. These features can help better distribute weight. Lower heels can also cause problems, but to a lesser degree. Look for wide toe boxes, rubber soles, and wedge heels. They provide more support and stability than the narrower heel.
When shoes like these have no arch supports in them – and they usually dont – they put a great deal of pressure on your knees, hips, and back. This happens even more so when youre on your feet a lot. Plantar fasciitis is a common condition that occurs when fibrous tissue that runs along the bottom of your foot between your heel and toes becomes in inflamed from being overstretched.
This causes extreme pain in the heels, especially when you put weight on your feet after first getting out of bed or when you stand up after sitting for a long period of time. In extreme cases, the fascia can actually tear.
Perfect Shoes For Knee Pain
The perfect shoes for knee pain are high-quality athletic and running shoes. These shoes are flexible and offer the best cushioning and support to your feet.
Its a tough decision when it comes to finding the top shoes for knee pain. You want something that will be comfortable, provide adequate support and allow enough wiggle room without being too tight or loose but how do you know which ones are worth investing in? Research shows that not all brands are up-to-par.
Moreover, when buying a walking shoe, look for the flexible one, and you can bend it easily. Shoes that are stiffer or limit the foots range of motion are not ideal. Besides, buy the shoes with a thinner sole, as this will provide more comfort and curtail the pressure from your knees. Subtle heels can also be helpful in this case.
Recommended Reading: Can Knee Replacement Cause Neuropathy
Can Foot Problems Cause Knee Pain
Most people think that their knee hurting is the result of knee injuries or the diseases stated above. But your foot might also be the reason why they hurt. Have you noticed your foot and ankle feeling painful lately? Then the pain will radiate to your leg and eventually make its way up?
This may be because you have a foot or ankle condition that is affecting your leg and knee. A patient may not think that foot pain and knee pain are related, but it does happen sometimes.
Lets take a look at some of the possible causes of your foot pain which can radiate all the way to your knee and kneecap.
The Toes Graze The Tip Of The Shoes
If your shoes for running have no room for your toes to move, then you should avoid using them for running or for anything else. You should be able wiggle your toes easily. As the day goes on, and as you go about your routine, your legs and feet tend to expand and swell. Wearing shoes that are tight could result in pain at the end of the day.
Don’t Miss: Inversion Table After Hip Replacement
Suffering From Knee Pain Your Shoes May Be To Blame
Your knees support your weight during every step you take. Did you know that the shoes you wear might make the difference between enjoying your walk and walking in pain?
Shoes with good support keep the knee in alignment, reducing the potential causes of pain. Proper arch support can keep feet from rotating inward or pronating. Cushioning in the shoes can also reduce shock that can happen with each step.
Being closer to the ground is better for thigh muscles, as it requires them to work less hard. High heels tend to tip people forward, forcing the quadriceps to work harder to keep the knee in place. According to the Arthritis Foundation, different kinds of shoes can cause different kinds of problems for knees and feet.
Stand Up Straight To Feel Better
“When you slouch you are leaning forward and walking bent over at the waist and that posture will lead to knee pain,” says Bush-Joseph. “You want your head centered over your shoulders and your shoulders centered over your abdomen and pelvis. The more your body is off-center, the more you have to compensate for that with muscle activity. Those muscles eventually fatigue, causing strain on your joints.”
Having strong core muscles in your abdomen and lower back helps promote good posture and, ultimately, lessens the pressure on your knees. Exercises such as planks, back extensions, yoga and Pilates can help strengthen the core.
Heres how to do these exercises:
- Planks: Lie face down with your toes pointed to the floor. Put your forearms on the floor with your elbows at 90-degree angles. Tighten your abdominal and gluteal muscles and lift your body off the floor. Keep your back straight and hold for 15 to 45 seconds.
- Back extensions: Lie face down with elbows bent and hands on the floor. Keeping your hips on the floor, lift your head and shoulders up with your arms. Hold for 5 to 10 seconds and repeat five to 10 times.
Don’t Miss: Inversion Table For Knee Pain
How To Find Shoes That Can Ease Knee Pain
Choosing proper footwear is especially important for people with knee pain. Learn how to shop for knee-friendly footwear.
For people with knee pain, choosing footwear involves more than picking the right color and size. Thats because footwear can affect knee health. Its been shown that the kind of shoes you wear can impact the load put on the knee joints, making knee pain better or worse, says Steven Stuchin, MD, director of orthopedic surgery at NYU Hospital for Joint Diseases in New York City. To minimize knee pain, shop for footwear with the following tips in mind.
Look for well-cushioned footwear. This will help prevent shock to the knees. Its a little like walking on pillows, says Dr. Stuchin. Shoes with good cushioning can absorb the impact of the foot hitting the ground, preventing much of the shock from ever getting to the knees. Well-padded shoes will also help lessen the impact of walking on hard surfaces, such as concrete sidewalks.
Check the sole. Firm midsoles help reduce overpronation a type of gait common in people with low arches. Overpronation causes the lower leg and knee to rotate inward each time the foot hits the ground, says Elizabeth Kurtz, DPM, a podiatrist in Chicago and spokesperson for the American Podiatric Medical Association. This inward rotation can cause knee strain and pain.
Mens Dress Shoes Versus Mens Sneakers
Dress shoes, sneakers, and walking barefoot were evaluated in healthy men to see if knee joint torque is affected in a way similar to high heels for women. From the analysis, researchers concluded that mens dress shoes and sneakers do not significantly affect the knee in any way that would be associated with knee osteoarthritis.
Recommended Reading: Why Does My Knee Hurt When It’s Cold
The Problem With Heels
Shoes with a standing surface not parallel to the floor due to an elevated heel, such as dress shoes, running shoes, and boots, tip the bodys center of mass forward, causing the entire body to compensate in order to avoid falling. People who wear high-heeled shoes may stand or walk with their knees constantly bent to stay upright, Price said. Over time, the sustained knee flexion may lead to inflammation, pain, and additional musculoskeletal imbalances. In addition, an elevated heel may cause an anterior pelvic tilt, where the pelvis rotates forward, tilting up at the back and down at the front and resulting in excessive lumbar lordosis and compensatory shifts up the spine to the head.
Kade Paterson, MSD, post-doctoral research fellow, in the Department of Physiotherapy at the University of Melbourne, Australia, said its now well known that shoes with higher heels increase load within the tibiofemoral and patellofemoral joints, contributing to knee pain. Many standard athletic shoes have a heel height of 30 mm or more , which can increase knee load by more than 15%, he said. Shoes that have a lower heel height and pitch and are more flexible reduce load in these joints.
Finding The Best Shoes For You
If you have joint pain, youll likely want to try athletic or running shoes, as they have the best cushioning and support for your joints and overall orthopedic health.
But there are so many shoe brands claiming to have the best fit or the most support. However, research reveals that this is not always the case.
In fact, a 2016 study published in the Annals of Internal Medicine that studied 164 adults with knee osteoarthritis found that there was no difference in knee pain between those who walked with enhanced shoes and those who didnt.
Don’t Miss: How To Get Rid Of Knock Knees
How Do Wrong Shoes Cause Back Pain
There are three ways the wrong footwear can result in back pain:
- If the design of the shoes is poor, it fails to provide proper support to the feet. It can either compress it or offer insufficient support to the natural arch. In such cases, pain in the leg and back arises over time.
- An incorrect shoe takes away the ability of the feet to absorb shock. This triggers intense pain in both lower back and hips. In some instances, it can even fracture the hip bone or lead to a slipped disc.
- Shoes with long heels or wrong design push the pelvis forward and the hips backward. This posture can trigger irregular menses.