Cortisone Injection In Knee: Is It Better Than Physiotherapy
The results are in, and its not looking good for cortisone injections in knees. However, a study in the reputable NEJM comparing 1-3 cortisone injections to exercise prescribed by physiotherapists for knee arthritis shows much better results for exercise. So, what does this mean for a cortisone injection in knee?
Mayo Clinic Q And A: How Are Rotator Cuff Tears Treated
DEAR MAYO CLINIC: I injured my rotator cuff recently and was told I was not a candidate for surgery. However, a friend shared that there’s a new minimally invasive treatment option that uses a balloon implant. How does this procedure work, and how does it compare to traditional treatments?
ANSWER: The rotator cuff is a group of muscles critical for the strength, stability and function of the shoulder. Tears of the rotator cuff tendons are a common source of shoulder pain, weakness and other problems. Imaging studies, such as radiographs, MRIs or ultrasounds, are used to evaluate rotator cuff tears.
Physical therapy and the occasional use of cortisone injections may improve pain and function for some people with a torn rotator cuff. However, many rotator cuff tears do not improve with therapy, and in those circumstances, surgery needs to be considered.
Repair of the torn rotator cuff tendons is the most performed procedure when surgery is required. Most rotator cuff repairs are performed using arthroscopy. A small camera is inserted into the shoulder through a small incision or cut, and additional small cuts are used for instruments to complete the repair.
To understand how a temporary subacromial balloon works, it is important to understand what happens to the shoulder in the presence of an irreparable rotator cuff tear. Specifically, the ball of the shoulder moves up and rubs against another bone on top, the acromion.
How Long Do The Benefits From Cortisone Shots Last
Improvements in knee pain in from cortisone shots typically peak around two weeks and can persist for up to 24 weeks.6 After 24 weeks knee pain tends to return to its original intensity.2 Its also worth noting that after the first few weeks of treatment patients typically see very little benefits from cortisone shots compared with a placebo .
Don’t Miss: What To Do For Jumper’s Knee
Can Anyone Have A Cortisone Injection For Knee Pain
Both children and adults can have cortisone injections to relieve knee pain. However, there are a few situations in which you should not have the injection, or your doctor may suggest waiting.
If you have any allergies to the injections ingredients, you will not be able to safely have it. Your doctor may also suggest avoiding hydrocortisone and certain other cortisone injections if you have a family history of manic depression or depression. If you were recently vaccinated, have an infection, are pregnant, or have potentially come into contact with measles, chickenpox, or shingles, you will have to wait for the shot.
How Much Will Cortisone Injections Help My Knee Pain
Like any treatment, corticosteroid injections dont work for all patients, and when they are effective results vary. Just 40% of patients report feeling better after receiving cortisone shots for knee arthritis. Further, those responding well to the treatment appear to receive a minimal benefit. The effectiveness of cortisone shots is often judged relative to placebo saline injections which contain no actual medicinal ingredients. One month after undergoing treatment, those who received cortisone injections report feeling slightly better than those who received the placebo an average difference of 1 on a 10 point scale .5 Better yes, but only slightly so. You will have to weigh this benefit against the possible side-effects and long term consequences associated with the treatment.
Read Also: Where Is The Mcl In The Knee
What Conditions Do Cortisone Shots In The Knee Work For
Corticosteroids are used to treat a variety of knee conditions such as tendonitis, bursitis, and osteoarthritis .1 The first thing to note is that they are not considered a permanent solution. Corticosteroids can provide short term relief from knee pain but over time the beneficial effects will wear off. Because of this, the utility of corticosteroid injections is very situational. Professional athletes will often get injections to make it through key games during their season. Someone planning a long multi-week vacation may receive an injection to maximize mobility during their leisure time. Regardless of the cause of your knee pain, you should weigh the pros and cons of cortisone injections before deciding on treatment.
Is A Cortisone Shot Expensive
Another consideration when choosing a treatment for knee pain is the expense. A cortisone injection cost typically ranges from $100 to $300, but most insurance plans should cover at least part of the cost. Medicare B, for instance, covers cortisone knee injections.
A cortisone injection can be an easy, quick, and safe solution to knee pain for many patients. A joint specialist can give you more information and help you decide if this treatment is right for you.
Reach out if you have knee pain, whether you know what the cause is or not. Request an appointment to reach the joint specialists at EmergeOrtho. Our specialists can advise you and offer effective treatments and management strategies, including cortisone injections.
Medical Advice Disclaimer
This website does not provide medical advice. The information on this website is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. For questions regarding a medical condition or treatment, seek the advice of your doctor or other qualified healthcare providers. Never disregard professional medical advice because of something you read on this website. If you need medical advice or treatment, to schedule an appointment.
Join the EmergeOrtho E-Mail List
Stay informed about the latest orthopedic specialties, news, and upcoming events.
Recommended Reading: Can Dehydration Cause Knee Pain
What Causes Of Knee Pain Does A Steroid Shot Treat
A cortisone shot is a simple and fast-acting pain relief treatment forseveral types of arthritis that affect the knee joints:
Cortisone shots provide pain relief for these injuries. They also reduce swelling and help you get more mobile, promoting the healing of the injury. Whether or not the shot is enough treatment for an injury depends on its severity.
How Long Will My Knee Hurt After Steroid Injection
The length of time that knee pain will persist after a steroid injection can vary depending on the individual. Some people may find that their pain subsides relatively quickly, while others may experience more prolonged discomfort. In general, however, the majority of people will notice a significant reduction in pain within a few days to a week after the injection.
Read Also: How To Remove Knee Fat
Cortisone Is Not Your Knees Friend
Cortisone injections or corticosteroid injections more generally, have been around since the early 1950s to treat various conditions including knee pain. Initially, cortisone was viewed as a major medical breakthrough to treat arthritic and inflammatory conditions that were not well managed through drugs on the market at the time. Now, over 70 years later we have a plethora of evidence of what benefit they provide as well as the risks, side effects, and poor long term outcomes.
What Conditions Are Cortisone Shots Used To Treat
Cortisone shots can treat a variety of injuries and conditions that cause pain and swelling, including autoimmune diseases, in which the bodys immune system mistakenly attacks healthy cells.
Some of the most common conditions treated with cortisone injections include osteoarthritis , lower back pain , carpal tunnel syndrome , bursitis , and tendonitis .
Its important to note that cortisone injections are not typically the first line of treatment. Your medical provider may suggest other medications, lifestyle changes, or physical therapy first before addressing pain with a cortisone shot.
Recommended Reading: Shots For Arthritis In Knee
How Often Can You Get Cortisone Injections
Depending on the condition being treated and where the injection is given, you may receive injections as frequently as every month. For other conditions, doctors may advise that you only receive a few injections within one year.
Professional athletes sometimes get injections throughout their season, but this should only be done with careful consideration and discussions with an orthopaedic sports specialist and an athletic trainer, she says.
But for the weekend warriors or those who want to type, knit, or play a piano pain-free, constant injections are likely not needed.
Reduce Inflammation With Steroids
Corticosteroid injections are useful for treating flare-ups of OA pain and swelling with fluid buildup in the knee, Richmond says.
These injections help relieve symptoms by reducing inflammation in the joint. But theyâre not a perfect solution in every case. If you’re considering this treatment, keep this in mind:
They work quickly. These injections offer âvery rapidâ relief, usually within 24 to 48 hours, Richmond says.
The benefit is short-term. On average, the pain relief lasts from 6 to12 weeks, Richmond says. Often, thatâs long enough to get you through a flare-up of osteoarthritis until your symptoms subside.
You shouldnât use them frequently. A corticosteroid shot often works best the first time, Altman says. After that, they tend to give less relief.
In most cases, Richmond tells his patients they can use these shots two to three times a year. Using them too often may damage cells in the knee that make cartilage.
Read Also: Why Do My Knees Get Stiff After Sitting
Who Did The Researchers Test
People in this study were military staff with knee arthritis. Researchers put people into two groups: one group having physiotherapy and another receiving a cortisone injection. Overall, the physiotherapy group received eight treatment sessions over six weeks, while the cortisone injection group received up to 3 injections over 12 months.
How Often Can I Get Cortisone Shots
There is no rule as to how many cortisone injections can be given. Still, there may be some practical problems with long-term use.
If a cortisone shot wears off quickly or does not help, then doing it again may not be worth it. Repeated cortisone injections also increase the risk of side effects.
That’s why many healthcare providers limit the number of shots to usually no more than three in one year at the same site. But there are healthcare providers who use more cortisone than this, and still others who may recommend fewer shots.
Cortisone shots may not be recommended as a first-line treatment in younger people whose joints are still growing.
Talk with your healthcare provider about how often you can have an injection.
Also Check: How To Use Epsom Salt For Knee Pain
How Does A Cortisone Shot Help My Knee
A cortisone injection reduces inflammation in a specific area for 6 weeks to 6 months.
The length of pain relief depends on the location and the type of injury. While it is not a pain reliever, that is generally the effect of of reducing inflammation.
Cortisone is naturally produced in the body by the adrenal gland and released when the body is under stress. While, a cortisone shot is synthetically produced to mimic what the body produces.
It is indeed a steroid, just not the kind that bulks you up in the gym.
What Does Cortisone Do
Cortisone, also known as a corticosteroid or a steroid, is a hormone your body naturally produces via the adrenal glands. When delivered as a medication, corticosteroids reduce the activity of your immune system, which relieves inflammation and pain for people with different kinds of arthritis .
Corticosteroids comes in many different forms, which vary by how long they stay in your body, how easily they dissolve, and how quickly they take effect. They can either be delivered locally , or systemically . Systemic corticosteroids are usually taken orally or as injections into a vein or muscle. Local corticosteroids for arthritis can be given as an injection into a joint for other types of health issues, they can also be delivered as skin creams, eye drops, or ear drops.
Read Also: What Mm Knee Sleeve Should I Get
How Is It Taken
Your doctor or nurse will talk to you about the most appropriate steroid mixture and dose for you. This will depend on your condition and symptoms.
They may want to check your blood pressure and blood sugar levels before your first injection as steroid injections can cause these to rise. They might delay the injection if either is raised.
Depending on where the pain and inflammation is, steroids can be injected:
- directly into an inflamed joint, this is known as an intra-articular injection
- into the soft tissue close to the joint, which is called a peri-articular injection
- into a muscle, which is called an intra-muscular injection.
Most injections are quick and easy to perform. They will be carried out by a healthcare professional in a hospital, clinic or doctors surgery.
You may need an ultrasound scan to find where the inflammation is, so the steroid can be injected into a precise spot and have maximum benefit. An ultrasound scan uses high-frequency sound waves to create an image of part of the inside of a body. Many injections can be given without the need for ultrasound.
Sometimes youll be given a local anaesthetic with the steroid to reduce the discomfort of the injection. This would mean your pain should be relieved within minutes. The effects of local anaesthetics can wear off within half an hour, unless youve been given one that is long acting. You may have some numbness from the anaesthetic that could last up to 24 hours.
How To Do A Knee Injection
Carlin Senter, MD, and Elizabeth Marshall, MD, discuss how to properly perform a knee injection, focusing on the supplies needed and the proper anatomic landmarks, including a discussion of both the anterior and lateral joint lines approaches for injection. Dr. Senter demonstrates her preferred technique, the superior lateral approach with the patient in the supine position.
Dr. Carlin Senter is a primary care sports medicine doctor. She emphasizes helping patients of all ages stay active, reduce injury risk and achieve peak performance. She has particular interests in exercise counseling and exercise prescription …
Youre likely to see just four types of knee injury in practice, but tests and treatments vary depending on your patients age and goals. Sports medicine doctor Brian Feeley, MD, sets out his straightforward system for assessing and addressing …
©2002 – 2022 The Regents of The University of California
Read Also: Why Does My Knee Hurt When I Straighten It
The Pros And Cons Of Corticosteroid Injections
Corticosteroid injections are frequently used to treat orthopedic conditions such as arthritis, tendonitis, and muscle and joint inflammation. It is possible to reduce inflammation and make the patient feel better for a short period of time, but this is temporary. Corticosteroid injections should only be given to patients who require them, in the same way that any medication should be administered to you by a healthcare professional.
Things To Consider Before Getting A Cortisone Shot
Before taking the injection, you need to understand the goal. Its going to treat the inflammation, but its not going to resolve the underlying issue that created the pain.
Youll have to be committed to a long-term solution. Doing physical therapy or other treatments for strengthening weak muscles or inflamed joints.
Simply put, cortisone shots are used to calm symptoms. They wont resolve the underlying cause of the pain youre experiencing.
There are several risks to getting cortisone injections. Its important to consider them all for your particular case. We will dive in to them more in-depth later in this article.
Cortisone can make bone on bone injuries worse by thinning out the meniscus. These steroid injections are known to be toxic to cartilage, the connective tissue that keeps your bones from rubbing against one another.
While I had initially refused a shot, the Orthopedic recommended it as an option to see if reducing the inflammation would allow the knee to regain full mobility. Avoiding surgery sounded great to me, so I decided one shot was worth trying.
Repeated shots in to areas like the knee are what youll find I warn heavily against. The data is overwhelming about additional breakdown occurring from too many injections.
Don’t Miss: How To Treat Knee Inflammation
How Well Do Cortisone Injections Treat Knee Pain
Like any treatment, corticosteroid injections dont work for all patients, and when they are effective results vary. Just 40% of patients report feeling better after receiving cortisone shots for knee arthritis.
Further, those responding well to the treatment appear to receive a minimal benefit. The effectiveness of cortisone shots is often judged relative to placebo saline injections which contain no actual medicinal ingredients.
In one study, one month after undergoing treatment, those who received cortisone injections reported feeling slightly better than those who received the placebo an average difference of 1 on a 10 point scale.5 Better so yes, but only slightly so. You will have to weigh this benefit against the possible side-effects and long term consequences associated with the treatment.
So Cortisone Vs Hyaluronic Acid For Knee Pain: Which Is Better
In deciding which one to use, you need to consider several factors.
Hyaluronic or gel injections work best for people with little or no swelling and a grumpy jointfor example, a 45-year-old recreational footballer with mild arthritis of the knee. People need no significant downtime after gel injections. Also, these gel injections are suitable for people who are allergic to steroids or cant use steroids for medical reasons.
On the other hand, cortisone injections work best for those people who need a quick pain-relief fix. Usually, people with a swollen and painful joints are most suitable for a cortisone injection. A perfect example would be a swollen knee joint from acute gout. However, cortisone is not ideal for a longer-lasting effect on a grumpy joint. Also, there is evidence that repeated cortisone injections lead to more significant wear and tear in the cartilage and a faster conversion rate to knee replacement.
Finally, some people choose to have both injections. For example, people with a swollen joint choose to have cortisone first, followed by a hyaluronic injection four weeks later. In some cases, people choose to have both injections together simultaneously. Your doctor can speak to you about the best option for your particular case.
You May Like: How To Heal Your Knee Quickly